From Seeing Both Sides to Creating the Eight
Seeing both sides is a virtue in most settings. In a stuck organisation it can become the thing that keeps everyone stuck.
Seeing both sides of an argument is a virtue in most settings. In a stuck organisation it can become the thing that keeps everyone stuck.
When a group frames every issue as two sides, the conversation becomes a contest of legitimacy. Both sides can be reasonable. Both can point to evidence. The meeting ends with an agreement to consider it further, which means nothing changes.
The limitation is structural. Two sides produce a line, and a line has only two ends. A third option cannot appear because there is no space for it in the frame.
Creating the eight is a deliberate move away from the line. It asks what else is true, who else is affected, what would have to be true for another option to work, and what the group would choose if neither of the current options existed.
This is not compromise. Compromise splits the difference between two positions that were already too narrow. Creating the eight changes the question until a better option becomes visible.
It requires a facilitator, or at least a chair willing to hold the group in the uncomfortable middle for longer than usual. The pressure to return to the two familiar sides is strong, and it is usually strongest just before something new appears.
Most groups can do this. What they lack is not intelligence but a structure that makes it possible, and permission to use it.
Written by
David Sproules